IP Protection Matters
IP Protection Matters is a podcast interview series examining notable issues related to the protection of and threats to intellectual property. IP Protection Matters is a project of the Center for Individual Freedom.
Thu, 19 Nov 2026
Philip Warrick
Philip Warrick, former Counsel at Irell & Manella LLP in Washington, DC, discusses how the pendulum of intellectual property policy is swinging away from rights holders in the courts and elsewhere, how that has emboldened infringers and threatens innovation, and what Congress and the courts can do restore balance and certainty to the U.S. patent system.

Transcription

Giachino (00:05.0019 - 00:45.0616)

Welcome to IP Protection Matters. I'm your host, Renee Giachino. Today, we are joined by Philip Warrick, Counsel at Irell & Manella LLP in Washington, DC. Mr. Warrick’s practice is focused on intellectual property, including patent litigation, appellate and policy matters. He has worked in all three branches of government. Most recently as an Associate Solicitor for the US Patent and Trademark Office, which included serving as the USPTO's IP Counsel Detailee to US Senator Chris Coons.

We will be talking today about litigation in the intellectual property arena. Philip, welcome to IP Protection Matters. It's a pleasure to have you join me.

Warrick (00:45.0625 - 00:48.0015)

Hello, Renee. Thank you so much for having me. It's a pleasure.

Giachino (00:48.0835 - 01:05.0856)

I like to start these discussions by asking a somewhat routine question. The answer always seems to be a little different based on the guest, and that is why should we care about IP protection? In other words, why does IP protection matter?

Warrick (01:06.0236 - 01:59.0889)

It is such a great question. For me, I would say, just from firsthand experience, there's a powerful incentive not just to innovate and create that is fostered by the IP system, but really to bring the investments that are necessary to turn those ideas into products that you could bring to market.

This is particularly true in some industries where you have these tremendous hurdles of time, regulation and money, as well as other resources, to jump through all the hoops that are required to first refine the idea into something that you know works and is useful in a reliable way. Then also, in many cases, to work through - whether it's regulations or other things - that are required to bring the product to market.

Giachino (02:00.0610 - 02:26.0669)

Speaking of working through, let's talk about working through our judicial system - litigation. You recently served on an excellent panel on litigation leadership that was hosted by the IP Policy Institute.

IP litigation is certainly an area in which you have dedicated your career. What do you see as the biggest changes over the years when we talk about IP litigation?

Warrick (02:27.0169 - 05:12.0079)

There have been so many changes since I've been involved. I was first exposed to intellectual property law even before I went to law school. I worked at a law firm in Ohio. That's when I took the patent bar. This was roughly 25 years ago. I'm told by others, and I've certainly seen in my lifetime, that the pendulum of intellectual property policy, both in the courts and in other ways, has kind of swung between the rights holders and those who are accused of infringing those rights.

But what I've seen most recently is very much the pendulum swinging away from the rights holders. I think it all started somewhere in the late 2000s where the Supreme Court really started paying attention to the Federal Circuit. It seemed like they had given that particular appellate court a lot of leeway for many years. It's the newest appellate court.

But there was a renewed sense of scrutiny. The law started changing in ways that made it more difficult for a patent owner to prevail. Those included tightening up obviousness law. We eventually had a huge sea change in the type of subject matter that is eligible for patent protections. Maybe most notably, the eBay decision made it much more difficult to secure an injunction, which is interesting because a patent is by definition a right to exclude. It is now very difficult, except in some competitor cases, to secure an injunction.

I'd like to come back to that, but we also had changes in Congress. We had the America Invents Act. It's the most significant patent legislation since the 1950s. That introduced a whole new administrative tribunal where you can come back to the PTO and challenge an existing patent without the presumption of validity and at a lower burden of proof than you would have in district courts.

There are other changes as well, but I think the net effect of all of these changes is that if you are an accused infringer, a lot of the incentives to settle a case early are gone, especially if you are a large, entrenched player and you're facing a suit by a smaller upstart. The cost of litigation and the time it takes to litigate are so burdensome that there's very little, in most cases, penalty for dragging it out. So it's almost the smartest tactical decision to drag it out as long as possible.

Giachino (05:12.0660 - 05:30.0869)

Philip, is there a number that you can attach to either the cost and/or the time that these cases are taking when they are being dragged out through the court system? Or even through the administrative system?

Warrick (05:30.0869 - 07:13.0769)

I'm not sure if you're asking for a dollar sign or a temporal figure. It varies a lot by case. I know some organizations like AIPLA have assembled statistics. I know from personal experience that a major patent litigation in district court can easily exceed $10 million in fees from the beginning of the pre-suit investigation through the end of a jury trial.

Depending on where you are litigating, there are some courts that expedite these cases. Certain courts in Texas have that reputation. Eastern District of Virginia is known as the “rocket docket.” But in some courts, this can take many years, particularly if things are paused while the PTAB at the USPTO is reevaluating some of the patents.

Then on top of that, almost every case is appealed. This is partially because of the incentives I mentioned before, and also because for certain legal issues there's been a very high reversal rate at the federal circuit. It can be difficult to settle on appeal. Right now, if you appeal you'll have somewhere in the region of several months of briefing. Then there's currently somewhat of a backlog. I'm hoping that it's coming down, but right now you have roughly a year from then until an argument. Then perhaps a couple of more months until you get a decision. If it does get reversed, then you go back to the district court and you redo some of it. You come back on appeal again. So it's just a very long and very expensive process.

Giachino (07:14.0149 - 07:33.0494)

Very cumbersome. We know that secure and effective patent rights, as we've talked about in so many instances, are essential to investing in research and development. These uncertainties that we are seeing in patent law, in patent litigation, are they threatening the future of innovation?

Warrick (07:33.0584 - 08:53.0229)

I think there's a very real risk of that. Very much so. It's very hard as a policy matter because it's easy to see the fruits of past innovation, past research and development and past commercialization efforts because we have these products that are available now. They're very important products.

Ironically, it is almost as if the more important the product, the more pressure there is to lower the price of those products, which makes sense because we want everyone to have access. But it takes a certain amount of long-term vision to think about the incentives for bringing the next generation of innovations and products to market. I do worry about that.

This goes back to that conference you mentioned earlier. I was on a panel and we were talking about the threat to America as not only an innovation leader, but as the gold standard for litigating these intellectual property disputes or resolving these intellectual property disputes. Because of uncertainties, costs and time, you see a lot of litigants who are choosing to primarily fight these battles in foreign jurisdictions.

Giachino (08:53.0900 - 09:19.0739)

Right. At the conference, you discussed how the major IP litigation is now being heard in more global markets and jurisdictions. Even IP that's been innovated here is being tested in the jurisdictions beyond the United States borders. Can you help us better understand the different venues where IP litigation is taking place in the global arena? Maybe start by educating us on the UPC.

Warrick (09:20.0280 - 11:02.0140)

Sure and with the caveat that I certainly have more expertise in the United States system. I don't practice in these other jurisdictions. The UPC is relatively new and in theory gives you a chance to resolve patent disputes across various states in the EU in a way that's less expensive and less fractured than going to countries individually.

In terms of where people are litigating, certainly we're still in the phase feeling the waters of the UPC, but there are jurisdictions that have proven to offer various things that would be appealing to different litigants depending on where you're situated. One thing would be the ability to get injunctions. I mentioned earlier that this is very difficult now in the United States for most people.

But in certain jurisdictions, traditionally in Europe, there are several jurisdictions. Brazil comes to mind as another place where people might not think of initially, but has become a hotbed for patent litigation. If you're able to get an injunction that shuts down a product or a data center or something along those lines, it brings people to the negotiation table in a very serious way because there's a threat that this patent might actually be an impediment to the business model in a much different way than saying we'll just keep paying legal bills for the next four years.

Giachino (11:02.0479 - 11:34.0974)

I'd like to go back in time a little bit to when you served as an IP Council Detailee spearheading legislative efforts and providing policy counsel to Senator Coons, who I deemed to be, and lots of folks do, one of the champions of IP protection in the United States. You were serving in that role together for him and the US Senate Judiciary Committee.

Can you share what you believe were some of the greatest accomplishments you had, or rather I guess you could say the committee had, while you were in that role?

Warrick (11:35.0195 - 14:54.0869)

Sure. I'll first say it was just a tremendous privilege to work with Senator Coons. He is a champion for intellectual property. He's someone who is truly passionate about it, not because someone lobbied him or anything like that. He just genuinely has an appreciation for innovation, for creativity and for what it takes to bring all of that to the market. It was an amazing opportunity that I did not anticipate. I was actually loaned from the patent office to Senator Coons and the committee.

In terms of what happened while I was there, I will first say that it is tremendously difficult to move a lot of the patent reform that the people are talking about right now. Some IP legislation can actually be somewhat easy in a certain way because it's not partisan. It's not Republican. It's not a Democrat issue. So sometimes, especially if there's a narrow targeted bill, it can be easy to bring people together and no one really opposes it.

But when you're talking about things that could have a big impact on the structure or cost of litigation, it's almost ironic, the nonpartisan nature of it almost cuts the other way because you can't just wait for your party to be in power and muscle something through. You really do have to forge consensus and then you run into a couple of tremendous hurdles.

One, you have very deep pockets on both sides. I'm, of course, broadly generalizing. If you have folks who more often than not find themselves on the defense side of the V, they are going to look at patent litigation as a cost and something of a nuisance in many cases or an impediment to what they're trying to do. You have other people on the other side of the V where enforcing their intellectual property is the cornerstone of their entire existence. There's a lot of money on both sides. There's a lot of lobbying on both sides for good reason.

This brings us to the next hurdle, which is that most Members of Congress, most staff members as well, know very little about intellectual property. This is such a niche issue on Capitol Hill. There's so much education that needs to be done. I ran into this when I was a staffer. I realized very quickly that I thought I was dumbing down some of the IP policy issues I wanted to talk about with other offices. I realized I was still way too far in the weeds. People need to go really back to basics. What is a patent? What is a trademark? Why do they matter? How do companies use them?

Lacking that, you have offices who have people coming from one side and saying, if you pass this bill it's going to destroy the economy. People on the other side saying no, it's the opposite. The economy is doomed unless you pass it. The easiest thing is to do nothing. It's much easier on Capitol Hill to stop a bill than it is to push a bill through.

Giachino (14:55.0450 - 15:15.0369)

We are seeing that definitely when we talk about things like the RESTORE Act that's been introduced and reintroduced. PERA is another critically important piece of legislation. The PREVAIL Act. Time and time again, I'm sure even when you were the Detailee, some of these ideas were being considered, right?

Warrick (15:15.0570 - 17:23.0130)

Absolutely. The PREVAIL Act has its roots in the Stronger Patents Act, which was floating around when I was there. Before that, it was called the Strong Patents Act. That's one of Senator Coon's signature bills. It's evolved over time, but it's really designed to try to remedy some of the unintended consequences of the America Invents Act back in 2011.

There is a huge effort that is still is being made to push that forward, but it's difficult for all the reasons I mentioned. PERA, by the same token, goes back to when I first joined the Senator's office in 2019. We worked closely with Senator Tillis. We had a series of three patent eligibility hearings with 45 witnesses, which is almost unheard of. It's a little bit crazy in hindsight. We had a draft proposal that didn't end up going anywhere. But the efforts continued, and those same efforts eventually brought about PERA.

They're both very important pieces of legislation, but very hard to move. I would say there's always hope. You always keep pushing the ball forward. Keep the conversation going. Part of what's happening with these bills even being in discussion is you're educating people on the Hill, which is important for all the reasons I mentioned. Things can happen.

You asked earlier about accomplishments while I was there. I would take very little credit for any of this, but we did have three IP bills passed during my time. We had the Trademark Modernization Act. We had the CASE Act, which created a small claims tribunal for copyright matters. We had another copyright bill that closed a loophole for felony streaming for a law that had been written really thinking about physical media like DVDs and modernizing that for the internet era.

Giachino (17:23.0280 - 18:07.0189)

I want to go back to something you mentioned that you said we could circle back to. That is the eBay decision. We're 20 years out now from that decision. Is my math right? Was that 2000? So just about 20 years out, but that has had a significant, in my opinion, negative impact on patent law in the United States, particularly in providing to ensure we retain these strong reliable and predictable IP rights for innovators and investors.

Share with us your thoughts on that case. Do you think we will see any relief anytime soon, ideally at the legislative level as it relates to the eBay decision?

Warrick (18:07.0609 - 21:03.0569)

I do agree. It is a tremendously important case. It had a huge impact. I think, personally, it threw things out of balance in terms of the law changing. There is some room, I believe, for the federal circuit itself to interpret the eBay decision a little bit differently in a way that would bring some balance. Certainly, the Supreme Court could change the law. I think there's a very small chance of that happening.

Legislatively, there is a bill pending called the RESTORE Act. It's been around for a little while now. It's a simple bill. The actual legislative text is just one sentence. What it would do is it would bring back a presumption that there is injunctive relief once you establish infringement. As like with any other presumption that could be rebutted for various reasons. After all, an injunction is equitable relief. So that's appropriate.

But bringing back the idea that is the default remedy if the patent owner wants it. I think it's very difficult because going back to the folks who find themselves only encountering the patent system as an infringement defendant, your view of this is going to be shaped by that experience. You're going to fight very hard against someone who wants to have leverage to shut down a product line or a service, or whatever it is that's central to your business model.

So I think it is very hard at this point to shift the law. I think it would make a huge difference. Not because I think there are so many patent owners who are actually trying to shut down products or services at the end of the day, but they do want to be compensated for their ideas and the investments they've made. In many cases, they don't have a good avenue for that because without that threat of injunctive relief that they're supposedly entitled to with the patent, how do you bring someone to the table? What you have is both sides litigating for years.

If you are the innovative upstart looking to disrupt the industry, your investors probably don't want to pay for four or five years of patent litigation. But some entrenched player on the other side, they can weather out four or five years of patent litigation. They may be annoyed, they may not want to pay those legal bills, but to the extent that they think there is value in the intellectual property, there's a good chance they'd be able to buy it for pennies on the dollar down the road. Something seems wrong with that system to me.

Giachino (21:04.0319 - 21:30.0290)

I really appreciate you educating us on all of this in the area of patent litigation. Our guest has been Philip Warrick, Counsel at Irell Manella LLP.

Philip, before I let you go, would you suggest that there are any big litigation cases in the arena, whether it's the global arena or here in the United States, as it relates to IP protection that we should be closely watching?

Warrick (21:30.0449 - 22:39.0650)

That's a great question. At any given time there are cases that are of significant importance that are pending. For example, the Supreme Court has one now having to do with so-called “skinny labels” for pharmaceutical products. I would say just bigger picture the issues I would watch really are in the standard essential area.

There's a huge fight that is international in nature about how courts can and should resolve those disputes and can you have one court in one country effectively setting a royalty rate for a patent or more likely a portfolio of patents internationally. That has huge consequences because standards are essential to so many of the products we use every day. Those disputes are very complex in nature.

This has invoked so many issues having to do with international law and comedy that are just very complicated. It's an active issue. I'm certainly keeping my eye on that one.

Giachino (22:40.0030 - 23:08.0229)

We will as well. We'd love to have you come back, join us and update us on some of these important issues, particularly as they relate to patent litigation in this arena.

Our guest has been Philip Warrick, Counsel at Irell and Manella LLP in Washington, DC. We greatly appreciate your time today. I encourage all listeners to go visit our website IPprotectionmatters.org and listen to some of the other interviews.

Philip, thank you again for your time. Have a wonderful day.